Offering Financing to Customers: What It Really Does to Your Average Ticket (Mantel Data)

Most shops treat financing as a rescue move. The homeowner balks at the total, the seller brings out the payment sheet, and offering financing to customers becomes the way to save a deal that's slipping. Many sellers assume financing is for price-sensitive homeowners and drags tickets toward the cheapest option.
Data from Mantel, the shopping and closing platform for home services, points the other way. Sales closed with financing in the first half of 2026 carried a 28.5% higher average ticket than sales paid by cash or card.
For a sales manager, that points to one habit worth building. Your seller shows financing on every job, meaning every visit to a home, before the homeowner asks for it.
What Mantel's data shows about financing and average ticket
Mantel looked at more than 24,000 proposals sold through its platform in the first half of 2026, across HVAC, plumbing, electrical and garage door jobs. Financed sales carried a 28.5% higher average ticket than cash or card sales.
What it says: When a homeowner financed, the job they bought was 28.5% bigger on average.
Why it's a percentage: Tickets vary too much across trades for one dollar figure to help. A garage door and a heat pump don't belong in the same average.
What it doesn't prove: Financing may not cause the whole lift. A homeowner replacing an entire system may finance because the job is already bigger.
What it leaves out: Close rate, because the data only counts sold proposals. The Air Conditioning Contractors of America (ACCA) Contractor of the Future study covers that side: contractors who offered financing averaged a 49% close rate, versus 38% for those who didn't.
Test the 28.5% on your own jobs, by seller, before you set targets around it.
Leading with financing turns a total into a choice
A monthly payment shrinks the gap between two big totals into a number the homeowner can weigh on the spot.
Many shops show five options, named Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum and Diamond from basic to best. The figures in this HVAC financing example are made up. A $14,000 Silver option and an $18,000 Gold option sit $4,000 apart. At 9.99% over 10 years, they come to about $185 and $238 a month. The homeowner is now deciding whether quieter operation, better humidity control, and a longer warranty are worth about $53 a month.
Other trades work the same way: a tankless water heater next to a tank replacement, a panel upgrade with a generator inlet, or an insulated garage door with a smart opener all get easier to compare per month.
Price also matters less to homeowners than many sellers assume. In the Mantel Homeowner Shopping Attitudes Report 2025 (n=422), only 31% ranked upfront cost as their #1 priority. As Zac Dearing puts it, price is only the most important thing if you don't know anything else.
Payments also move homeowners off the bottom option. In the same ACCA study, contractors who never offered financing sold base models on 50% of sales, versus 35% for contractors who always did. When the step up shows as a monthly difference, fewer homeowners settle for Bronze.
To build the tiers themselves, use our guide to the 5 HVAC options to show homeowners.
Why sellers skip financing at the kitchen table
Sellers skip financing for 3 reasons, and each one traces back to how the shop sets up the visit.
They assume the homeowner will pay cash: The house is paid off, or the couple is retired, so financing feels unnecessary. You can't read a household's finances from the driveway, though. In the Federal Reserve's Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2025 report, 63% of adults said they'd cover a hypothetical $400 emergency expense with cash or its equivalent. A replacement costs many times that, and plenty of homeowners who could pay cash would prefer to keep it.
They don't want to seem pushy: Asking "will you be financing today?" feels personal, so careful sellers avoid it. A payment printed on every option answers that question without anyone having to ask it. Money also comes up more easily once the homeowner feels heard during the visit.
It's slow to set up: If quoting a payment means a separate lender portal, a calculator, and 10 minutes of typing, sellers save it for deals that are slipping.
Fix the setup first, then coach the seller.
How to make offering financing to customers part of every job
Four habits make financing show up on every job.
Make it standard on every job: Write it into your process for every trade, including repair-to-replace conversations, and set up your home improvement financing so every seller can quote it from the same screen. "Financing on every proposal" is a rule a new seller can follow on day one. "Offer it when it seems right" depends on judgment that takes years to build.
Show a payment on every option, Bronze through Diamond: Put the monthly figure next to the total so the homeowner can compare both ways. When add-ons change on a tablet, the payment should change with them, which is one reason a digital proposal changes the kitchen table. Your lender takes care of credit disclosures. If you put payment figures in your marketing, run them past your lender or attorney first, since the CFPB's rules on advertising credit terms under Regulation Z (the Truth in Lending rule) apply.
Keep financing in the follow-up: Many replacement decisions get made after the seller leaves. The proposal the homeowner revisits should still show the monthly payment on every option, so the comparison they make at home matches the one they saw with your seller. Send the quote the same day so the numbers are fresh. If the quote doesn't sell at the kitchen table, it moves to rehash, which half the industry calls inside sales. Rehash usually opens with the happy call, a next-day call to ask whether the homeowner was happy with the visit. On the touch after that, have your inside sales rep lead with the payment difference between the option the homeowner leaned toward and the one above it. "Are you still interested?" gives the homeowner nothing new to think about. A rehash program that leads with financing gives them a reason to call back.
Track it by seller every week: For each seller, count the jobs where financing appeared on every option. Then compare average ticket on their financed and cash sales. Pair it with sales per job run (total sales divided by jobs run, which equals close rate times average ticket), because average ticket can rise while sales per job run falls. Our piece on measuring average ticket without fooling yourself walks through the math. Compare against the same season last year so a heat wave doesn't take the credit.
Habit | What it fixes | What to check each week |
|---|---|---|
Standard on every job | Sellers assuming the homeowner will pay cash | Share of jobs with financing on the proposal |
Payment on every option | Fear of seeming pushy, slow setup | Share of options showing a monthly payment |
Financing in the follow-up | Deals going quiet after the visit | Rehash contacts that opened with a payment difference |
Track by seller | Shop averages hiding individual gaps | Average ticket, financed vs. cash, and each seller's sales per job run |
If you're evaluating proposal tools this year, ask the vendor to prove the second habit live. "Does it lead with financing every time?" is one of the questions in our HVAC proposal software checklist.
FAQ
does offering financing actually raise average ticket?
In Mantel's data from the first half of 2026, financed sales carried a 28.5% higher average ticket than cash or card sales. The data shows the two move together, and it can't prove financing caused the lift. Test it on your own jobs, by seller, across a full season before you set targets around it.
won't financing just push people toward the cheapest option?
Usually it does the opposite. A monthly payment shrinks the visible gap between tiers, so stepping up feels like a small comfort decision. In ACCA's study, contractors who always offered financing sold base models on 35% of sales, versus 50% for those who never did.
should my sellers ask whether the homeowner wants to finance?
No. Have them show the payment on every option. A question about financing feels personal and invites a reflexive "we'll pay cash." A number on the screen lets the homeowner decide privately.
does financing make sense on smaller jobs like a water heater?
Yes, if your lender's minimums allow it. A monthly figure still helps a homeowner compare a standard tank with a tankless or high-efficiency option. Check your lender's program terms, since minimum amounts and plan lengths vary.
One change to make this week
Pull last week's proposals for 1 seller and count how many showed a monthly payment on every option. That count tells you whether your team leads with financing or saves it for slipping deals, and it gives you a baseline to coach against.
Mantel builds that habit into the proposal itself. With SmartQuote, sellers build five options in minutes and homeowners shop options, add-ons and ways to pay on one screen, so a monthly payment shows up on every job without anyone asking. Its Dynamic Financing updates discounts instantly as the homeowner switches payment methods, so your shop recovers the fee the lender charges on each financed sale.


